# Review rubric

Assess six dimensions: discoverability, scope, procedure, safety, resources, and proof.

For each finding, state the observed evidence, the practical consequence, and the smallest helpful change. Do not call missing files a problem unless the workflow genuinely needs them. A strong review explains why the recommendation belongs in the skill rather than in general agent behavior.

Test prompts should include one normal request and one boundary case. Assertions should be observable, such as valid JSON, an explicit approval request before mutation, or a report containing file locations.
