# Gates: review desk privacy and improved-draft audit

OWNS: src/pages/skills-review.astro, src/components/blocks/{ReviewDetail,
ChangeLens,VoteWidget,PreviewPane,FileTabs}.astro, legacy/skills-review/**,
submitted-skills/Anonymous Operational Submission/**,
skill-reviews/improved/ndo-repro/**, scripts/verify.mjs

The gate commands below now read `dist/`; run `pnpm run build` before them.

Scope: Redact the operational submission's identity and URLs from the published
review desk, keep package files usable in either preview mode, and explain each
improved draft as a concrete diff.

- [x] G1: the published operational submission contains no personal name,
      original source URL, email address, or host-specific path CHECK: node
      scripts/verify.mjs EXPECT: review privacy verification passed EVIDENCE:
      exit=0; shell=/bin/sh; cwd=/home/marcos/Projects/ai-for-dummies;
      path=d3551337f830/34 entries; EXPECT=matched;
      output-sha256=180e8cd0d18968e2a4244ede959c3459b5ce80b836fc5a0df00961907e5d15a1;
      output-bytes=481

- [x] G2: every package file remains selectable in Original and Improved draft
      modes without resetting the selected preview CHECK: node
      scripts/verify.mjs EXPECT: review file-mode verification passed EVIDENCE:
      exit=0; shell=/bin/sh; cwd=/home/marcos/Projects/ai-for-dummies;
      path=d3551337f830/34 entries; EXPECT=matched;
      output-sha256=180e8cd0d18968e2a4244ede959c3459b5ce80b836fc5a0df00961907e5d15a1;
      output-bytes=481

- [x] G3: every improved draft has an interactive change lens that explains
      changed guidance and its rationale CHECK: node scripts/verify.mjs EXPECT:
      review change-lens verification passed EVIDENCE: exit=0; shell=/bin/sh;
      cwd=/home/marcos/Projects/ai-for-dummies; path=d3551337f830/34 entries;
      EXPECT=matched;
      output-sha256=180e8cd0d18968e2a4244ede959c3459b5ce80b836fc5a0df00961907e5d15a1;
      output-bytes=481

- [x] G4: the review desk works at mobile, Full HD, and 4K widths without page
      errors or horizontal overflow EVIDENCE: Playwright audit on 2026-09-04:
      320, 390, 1280, 1920, and 3840px passed with Improved Draft and Change
      lens rendered; no horizontal overflow or page errors.